That's... very true. No one I've talked to so far has noted that their age was wrong.

[It took Poe an while to notice his own hair's length change. And that's not good evidence, because it could've been cut while he was unconscious.]

But that brings up even more unwanted implications.... Specifically that whatever caused our memory loss is either extremely inaccurate in how much it erases, or the amount lost between each person corresponds to an set of reasons we are unaware of.

[G R E A T. This just keeps getting better and better.]